Wikler's Quest for Healthy Children's Feet

Posted on April 23, 2013 by Elf Martin There have been 2 comment(s)

Wikler's Quest for Healthy Children's Feet

In a recent blog post about Barefoot Pioneers, we recognized some of the people who stood up against popular opinion to show the world the benefits of natural foot function and the dangers of restrictive, inhibiting shoes. One of the pioneers we mentioned, Dr. Simon J. Wikler, seems to be lesser known than the rest. We thought he deserved a little more attention, especially for the contribution he made to curing and preventing foot health problems in children.

In 1933, Wikler graduated from Temple University School of Chiropody (now known as podiatry) and became a foot specialist. At that time, the practice of treating foot injuries focused on paring corns and callouses, padding sore feet and prescribing arch supports. Wikler stood out from his fellow chiropodists when he sought the source of foot injuries with the hope of curing them rather than just treating the symptoms. The attitude of his peers was summed up by one of his colleagues, an older physician who told him "Foot troubles are chronic conditions people have had for a long time… You'll waste your time trying to find their cause and cure."

Wikler's Quest for Healthy Children's Feet

Wikler's illustrations of unhealthy feet vs. healthy feet.

Despite this attitude, Wikler persisted with his research into the 1940s and 1950s, which involved interviewing thousands of people and studying a variety of cultures to compare foot health and habits that affect it. He considered existing theories that static electricity, water and sleeping with toes facing north could lead to healthy feet. The answer finally came to him through one of his patients, a two-and-a-half-year-old boy. The boy's feet were so wide that even the widest commercially-available shoes his parents could find would not allow his toes to spread. The boy suffered from fallen arches, walked awkwardly, tired frequently and fell often.

On his journeys abroad, Wikler met many people with strong, healthy feet who routinely walked and worked barefoot. He began to wonder if there could be a connection and advised the boy's mother to let the child go without shoes for the next few months. She agreed, and Wikler kept the boy under close observation to see the effects. The results amazed him:

"Going barefoot had made this boy's toe area broader and stronger. When he stood, his stronger toes were now able to spread out, giving him a broad forward area on which to support his weight. Now he used his toes in standing and walking—he would even stand on his toes frequently while playing. His fallen arches were cured. With better foot balance, he rarely fell. He no longer begged to be carried, and he seemed tireless in his activities."

Wikler's Quest for Healthy Children's Feet

Wikler ran with this new theory and spent the next ten years examining thousands of feet and performing tests in accredited hospitals. The results of his labor led him to this conclusion: "THE MAJOR CAUSE OF FOOT TROUBLE IS THE TYPE OF SHOES WE WEAR."

In 1961, Wikler published his findings in Take Off Your Shoes and Walk. The book explained his research, documented the history of how unhealthy footwear became prevalent in our society and provided extensive advice on how foot pain can be prevented and treated with less constrictive footwear or bare feet. The book focused primarily on developing children's feet and gave hope to many parents who saw their kids walking in pain. Wikler's recommendations are modified for various age groups from infants and toddlers to older walkers. These early ages, he believed, are when children are most vulnerable to foot deformities from inappropriate footwear, and also the best time to correct and prevent injury.

Here is some of Wiklers advice for children:

  • "Shoes that are flexible, roomy, and simply made are best. Remember, children's toes and feet must be allowed to grow naturally without restrictions and pressures."
  • "For infants, shoes without raised heels are the most desirable."
  • "Any shoes with arch support features are to be avoided."
  • "Occasionally one finds the old-style cowboy-boot-type shoes with their pointed toes. Do not under any circumstances purchase these."
  • "Going barefoot is a 'must' for young children"

All of these beliefs contradicted the views held by both doctors and the footwear industry of his day, and Wikler admitted often that finding healthy footwear for children in the 1960s was extremely challenging.

Wikler's Quest for Healthy Children's Feet

Fortunately for us, Wikler's beliefs are now commonplace. Although there are still many companies making rigid, constricting footwear for children, it is not difficult to find options for thin and flexible shoes. The idea that minimal shoes are best for kids has been popular for decades (Soft Star has been doing it since 1984), long before the barefoot running movement of the past few years, and this is largely the result of Wikler's work and his willingness to dissent against popular opinion.

Sadly, Take Off Your Shoes and Walk has long been out of print, but you can read very thorough fair-use excerpts of it at unshod.org.


This post was posted in Family, Foot Health and was tagged with barefoot, feet, foot, health, history, kids, children, arch, simon, wikler, take off your shoes and walk, fallen, support, podiatrist, chiropodist, foot doctor

2 Responses to Wikler's Quest for Healthy Children's Feet

  • Truth
    Truth says:

    LIES. The toes should point 10 to 2 for solid balance: JUST LIKE ACTION FIGURES. Toes pointing forward misaligns the ankles, knees, hips, AND back. But hey, it's ObamaCare, so who cares, right? You aren't paying for it! Well, not unless you count the lifetime of aches, pains, and crippling new posture you're inflicting on yourself AND others by pushing this ridiculousness. WAKE UP PEOPLE!!!!!!! Toes forward (except when running- on your TOES) is a way to get your money through medical procedures. It's reinforced by television because "toes pointing forward" uses the camera's limitations to convey slimmer hips. Go back and look at the introduction of the miniskirt in the UK to investigate how models were standing when the body was better regarded than it is today. SHILLS. All of this nonsense!

    Posted on July 13, 2017 at 12:24 AM

  • Elf Martin
    Elf Martin says:

    Hi T. While we appreciate your passion for foot health, I think you misinterpreted this article. Simon Wikler advocated shoes that allow toes to spread and move freely, but nowhere in here does it say anything about toes pointing forward. You may be drawing your assumptions from the roughly sketched illustration, which is only meant to show the difference of toes malformed by tapered shoes versus toes that spread out naturally. I don't see anything from this research suggesting that toes should point in any particular direction.

    Posted on July 13, 2017 at 12:18 PM

Comments